banner1.jpg (38669 bytes)

NOTES ON THE PRESENTATION OF BELL TUNING

When a bell is rung, it emits a number of different notes at the same time known as harmonics or partials. Bells most tuneful to the ear emit partials that have a fixed relationship to each other. A full explanation and description of the sound of bells may be found in Bill Hibbert’s work, The Sound of Bells, and a much better explanation of the relationship of the different partials may be found here.

Where bells form a ring which consists of a major scale (which is the vast majority), the interval between each bell can be subtly different from tower to tower. Different founders can adopt different scales, and again this is better explained in Bill Hibbert’s work.

The different partials of a particular bell and the relationship of one bell to another can be represented on paper in different ways using established presentations and a colour presentation which is an invention of my own. They are as follows:

1. By giving the individual frequencies of the different partials in Hertz.

These are empirical measurements, how frequencies are initially measured and is the raw form from which other calculations are made. The example given below is from the Gillett & Johnston ring of 8 bells from Bromley Parish Church.
 

Bell Hum Prime Tierce Quint Nominal Superquint OctNom
8 173 345 415 515 690 885 1017
7 194 387 466 582 776 1006 1154
6 216 431 518 647 862 1091 1437
5 230 460 552 690 920 1183 1327
4 259 518 622 776 1035 1321 1539
3 288 575 693 863 1150 1449 1713
2 323 647 778 970 1294 1867 1922
1 345 687 831 1028 1374 2013 2721
To help the reader interpret these figures better, a colour coding scheme is used to demonstrate where a partial is above or below true harmonic tuning with respect to the nominal, and give an indication of by how much. True harmonic partials are shown in green. The more red a rectangle is, the flatter the harmonic. The more blue a square is, the sharper the harmonic.

Bell

Hum

Prime

Tierce

Quint

Nominal

S'quint

O'nom.

8

173

345

415

515

690

1017

885

7

194

387

466

582

776

1006

1154

6

216

431

518

647

862

1091

1437

5

230

460

552

690

920

1327

1183

4

259

518

622

776

1035

1321

1539

3

288

575

693

863

1150

1449

1713

2

323

647

778

970

1294

1867

1922

1

345

687

831

1028

1374

2013

2721

2. By giving the same information but in the notation of notes and the variation from them in terms of cents.

This gives a bit more information that translates the frequencies into something more intuitive.

Bell

Hum

Prime

Tierce

Quint

Nominal

Superquint

OctNom

8

F(0)-21

F(1)-24

Ab(1)-1

C(2)-29

F(2)-21

A(2)+10

C(3)-50

7

G(0)-18

G(1)-22

Bb(1)-1

D(2)-16

G(2)-18

B(2)+32

D(3)-31

6

A(0)-36

A(1)-38

C(2)-19

E(2)-34

A(2)-36

C#(3)-28

F(3)+49

5

Bb(0)-23

Bb(1)-25

C#(2)-9

F(2)-21

Bb(2)-23

D(3)+12

E(3)+11

4

C(1)-19

C(2)-19

Eb(2)-2

G(2)-18

C(3)-19

E(3)+3

G(3)-32

3

D(1)-37

D(2)-37

F(2)-14

A(2)-35

D(3)-37

F#(3)-37

A(3)-47

2

E(1)-34

E(2)-32

G(2)-13

B(2)-31

E(3)-32

Bb(3)+2

B(3)-48

1

F(1)-21

F(2)-30

Ab(2)+1

C(3)-31

F(3)-29

B(3)+33

F(4)-46

3. By giving the relative intervals between frequencies of partials, both within a bell and between bells in a ring.

For individual bells, the partials are shown as cents above or below the nominal. However the figures in the “Nominal” column show the number of cents above the tenor nominal, with the tenor nominal figure showing as zero.

Bell

Hum

Prime

Tierce

Quint

Nominal

Superquint

OctNom

8

-2400

-1203

-880

-508

0

431

672

7

-2400

-1204

-883

-498

203

449

687

6

-2400

-1202

-883

-498

385

408

885

5

-2400

-1202

-886

-498

498

435

634

4

-2400

-1200

-883

-499

702

422

687

3

-2400

-1200

-877

-498

884

400

690

2

-2401

-1200

-881

-499

1089

635

685

1

-2392

-1201

-870

-502

1192

662

1183

Moving to the relationship of one bell to another, we have already seen a representation above in terms of cents. These can be compared with one or more of a number of “established” scales: Equal Temperament, Just Toned, Mean Toned and Pythagorian.

The intervals shown above are given with respect to the tenor nominal. The difference from the different scales can also be given with respect to the tenor nominal, and this is the way preferred by the bell tuners I have spoken to. However I am more inclined to show the difference with respect to the mean of the whole ring. I prefer the latter option since, if only the tenor is sharp or flat with respect to the rest of the ring, all the bells appear to be out of tune using the former option.

For Bromley, the examples are shown below:

Variations from the Mean of the Nominals:

Bell

Equal Temp.

 

Just Tuned

 

Mean Tone

 

Pythag.

8

0

 

-1

 

-4

 

3

7

5

 

-1

 

8

 

4

6

-11

 

0

 

-2

 

-16

5

3

 

1

 

-6

 

8

4

9

 

1

 

5

 

10

3

-8

 

2

 

-4

 

-9

2

-2

 

3

 

8

 

-7

1

3

 

-5

 

-5

 

8

Variations from the Tenor Nominal:

Bell

Equal Temp.

 

Just Tuned

 

Mean Tone

 

Pythag.

8

0

 

0

 

0

 

0

7

3

 

-1

 

10

 

-1

6

-15

 

-1

 

-1

 

-22

5

-2

 

0

 

-5

 

0

4

2

 

0

 

5

 

0

3

-16

 

0

 

-6

 

-22

2

-11

 

1

 

6

 

-21

1

-8

 

-8

 

-8

 

-8

Lovesguide will use different presentations as appropriate to the ring of bells to illustrate the nature of the ring.